| This is a
WorldNetDaily printer-friendly version of the article which follows.
To view this item online, visit http://www.worldnetdaily.com/index.php?pageId=189629
Friday, December 10, 2010 WorldNetDaily Exclusive Obama 'enjoying' eligibility dispute Lawmaker: 'You don't have to be born in the United States to be president' Posted: August 09, 2010 9:32 pm Eastern
By Bob
Unruh
A member of Congress from California says there's no need for the
president to have been born in the United States – or to have two parents
who are U.S. citizens – to be a "natural born citizen" and be eligible for
the Oval Office. U.S. Rep. Brian Bilbray,
R-Calif., told WND today that he believes President Obama, who's been
named as a defendant in multiple legal and other challenges claiming he is
not eligible to be president, is enjoying the dispute over his background.
Further, Bilbray said the document that Obama critics should be hunting
for is the passport he used when he traveled to Indonesia and other places
early in his life. The controversy over Bilbray's comments developed when a YouTube.com video
was posted. In the video of a television interview on "The Ed Show,"
Bilbray said, "It's just like people thinking that you gotta be born in
the United States to be president. You don't have to be. That's a legend.
We got to clarify that."
The video explains it was recorded about a week ago and appeared
shortly later on YouTube. The site indicates the video, which also has
extensive quotations about California Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger, was
posted by an organization opposing any attempt to change the Constitution
to allow Schwarzenegger, who was not born in the U.S., to seek the
presidency. It was highlighted by The
Post & Email website, where a commentator was surprised by the
statements. (Story continues below) In his analysis of the tape, David F. LaRocque wondered, "Where is this
guy from? Is he dealing with a full deck? New strategy
unveiled on answering Obama's eligibility questions. See how you can
help. "If the constitutional term 'natural born citizen' does not mean 'born
in the United States,' and it does not mean 'born of parents who are both
United States citizens,' what DOES it mean? "I am shocked, stunned, dumbfounded and totally dismayed that a person
serving in the U.S. House of Representatives could say such a thing," he
wrote. The
dispute over Obama arises from questions over his status as a "natural
born citizen." The Constitution, Article 2, Section 1, states, "No Person
except a natural born Citizen, or a Citizen of the United States, at the
time of the Adoption of this Constitution, shall be eligible to the Office
of President." WND has covered a multitude of cases, some of then challenging whether
Obama was actually born in Hawaii, as he insists. If he was born out of
the country, Obama's American mother, the suits contend, was too young at
the time of his birth to confer American citizenship to her son under the
law at the time. Other challenges have focused on Obama's citizenship through his
father, a Kenyan subject to the jurisdiction of the United Kingdom at the
time of his birth, thus making him a dual citizen. The cases contend the
framers of the Constitution excluded dual citizens from qualifying as
natural born. Further, others question his citizenship by virtue of his attendance in
Indonesian schools during his childhood and question on what passport did
he travel to Pakistan three decades ago. Adding fuel to the fire is Obama's persistent refusal to release
documents that could provide answers and his appointment of lawyers to
defend against all requests for his documentation. At stake is whether the U.S. actually has elected and sworn into office
a presidential candidate who does not meet the Constitution's demands for
eligibility. While his supporters cite an online version of a "Certification of Live
Birth" from Hawaii as his birth verification, critics point out such
documents actually were issued for children not born in the state. Bilbray disagreed with most of the arguments raised by the challenges.
He said a natural born citizen is someone who is born in the U.S. or
overseas if the birth is registered with the government. He said the key is having a parent who has an obligation to the United
States, such as Obama's mother. Bilbray said it doesn't matter that
Obama's father, governed by his Kenyan nationality, was a British subject
when Obama was born. But he also explained parents can denounce a U.S. citizenship for a
child, and that's why Obama critics should be hunting not for any birth
documentation but the passports on which Obama traveled earlier in his
life. Personally, Bilbray said he believes Obama was born in Hawaii, "but I
don't know what his status is." "He's a U.S. citizen until proven otherwise," he said. "I think the president is enjoying this exercise," he told WND. "I
think he doesn't want to clarify it. I think he's enjoying it. "It's an exercise that he uses to try to discredit his opponents. A lot
of this is a distraction. This citizenship issue is used as a way of
distracting from what he's doing politically," he said. He called Obama the "most extreme left-wing president ever." The
Post & Email noted that several of the attorneys who have been
fighting the Obama eligibility cases, Mario Apuzzo and Leo Donofio, have
done extensive research on the meanings, the wording and the origins of
"natural born citizen." "Each of them has established, independently and conclusively, that the
'natural born Citizen' requirement of Article II of the United States
Constitution clearly has its origins in the work of the political
philosopher Emmerich de Vattel, who defined 'natural born Citizen' as
meaning 'born in the country of parents who are citizens,'" the commentary
said. It continued, "The U.S. congressman, Brian Bilbray, who was captured on
video making an unfounded and false statement regarding an extremely
important and significant provision of the United States Constitution in a
public television appearance, is exposing himself as seriously uninformed
regarding that document. In fact, one could argue that this public
misrepresentation of such an essential requirement of the U.S.
Constitution renders this man unfit to serve in public office," it said.
On the YouTube website, one of the forum participants lost his cool:
"Bilbray is a JACKASS! The Naturalized LAW is not a 'legend,' it's a
Constitutional REQUIREMENT. This stupid idiot actually got voted into
office?!?!" Related offers: Get the
most comprehensive special report ever produced on the Obama eligibility
issue. New strategy
unveiled today on answering Obama's eligibility questions. See how you can
help. Related stories: Obama's
eligibility doubted by surging congressional candidate Candidate
for Congress: 'Usurper' holds Oval Office Black
candidate wonders if Obama 'entitled' to office Senator:
Resolve eligibility in court Congressman
on birth certificate: 'There's 1 we haven't seen' Congressman
says Obama birthplace 'not in Hawaii' Mayor
joins chorus questioning if Obama 'American' 'I
don't know whether Obama's a U.S. citizen' NPR
changes archive regarding president's birth Kenyan
officials affirm: Obama 'son of this soil' Kenyan
official: Obama born here NPR
archive describes Obama as 'Kenyan-born' THE FULL
STORY: See listing of more than 200 exclusive WND reports on the
eligibility
issue |